Signature Design by Ashley MakingMoves Rocker Recliner vs Signature Design by Ashley McGann Brown Rocker Recliner (2026): Key Differences
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
This comparison looks at the signature design by ashley makingmoves rocker recliner vs mcgann brown models. Both chairs offer manual rocker reclining and faux leather upholstery that spot cleans easily. They share reinforced frames for daily stability. The main difference lies in their sizing and setup. The McGann is a standard width chair requiring assembly, while the MakingMoves is an oversized model that arrives fully constructed. You should consider which dimensions and preparation effort fit your space and body type best.
Key differences
| Aspect | Signature Design by Ashley McGann Rocker Recliner | Signature Design by Ashley MakingMoves Rocker Recliner |
|---|---|---|
| Reclining Mechanism | One pull reclining | Manual pull tab |
| Seat Width | 17 inches | 22 inches |
| Assembly | Easy assembly required | No assembly required |
| Overall Height | 40 inches | 42 inches |
| Weight Capacity | 250 pounds | not listed |
| Extra Features | Plush pillow-top arms | Pop-out arm cupholders |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Signature Design by Ashley McGann Rocker Recliner if
- You prefer a narrower seat that fits through standard doorways
- You are comfortable with a short assembly process
- You want a chair with a specified 250-pound weight limit
Choose Signature Design by Ashley MakingMoves Rocker Recliner if
- You need a wider seat for broader comfort
- You want a chair ready to use immediately without setup
- You value built-in cupholders for convenience
Verdict: Choose the McGann if you need a standard-width recliner and do not mind assembling it. Pick the MakingMoves if you prefer an oversized seat and want zero assembly time. Both provide reliable rocker motion and easy-to-clean faux leather surfaces.
Comparing Two Ashley Rocker Recliners
Reclining Mechanism
The McGann Brown uses a one-pull reclining action to release the footrest. This simple motion allows for gentle rocking and smooth adjustment. The MakingMoves chair also features a manual pull tab for reclining. It extends to a full 67-inch length when fully reclined. Both chairs rely on manual operation rather than electric motors. You control the angle with a simple pull. The McGann focuses on a straightforward release, while the MakingMoves emphasizes the extended length for lying down. Both mechanisms are reliable for daily use without complex electronics.
Motion Type
Both the Signature Design by Ashley MakingMoves Rocker Recliner and the McGann Brown Rocker Recliner feature a rocker motion. This means the base allows you to rock back and forth gently. This motion is soothing and helps with relaxation. Neither chair offers a gliding motion or a stationary base. The rocker mechanism is integrated into the frame design for both models. This shared feature makes them suitable for nurseries or living rooms where a gentle sway is desired. The rocking action complements the reclining function in both units.
Upholstery Material
Both recliners are upholstered in faux leather. The McGann Brown is described as having a warm feel with a blend of 97% polyester and 3% polyurethane. The MakingMoves chair also uses a faux leather blend of 97% polyester and 3% PU. Both materials are designed to be easy to spot clean with water-based cleaners. This makes maintenance simple for everyday spills. The material provides a sophisticated aesthetic for both chairs. You do not need special leather conditioners. Both options offer similar durability and cleaning requirements for home environments.
Target Audience
The MakingMoves Rocker Recliner is crafted for broader and taller individuals. It features a spacious 22-inch seat width and a 23-inch seat depth. The overall height is 42 inches, providing more room for larger frames. In contrast, the McGann Brown has a 40-inch overall width and a 17-inch interior seat width. This makes the McGann a better fit for average-sized users. The McGann also includes plush pillow-top arms for a contouring fit. If you need extra seating space, the MakingMoves is the practical choice.
Features
The MakingMoves Rocker Recliner includes pop-out arm cupholders. This feature keeps beverages close within easy reach while you recline. It adds convenience for watching TV or reading. The McGann Brown does not list any cupholders or storage features in its specifications. It focuses on a clean, simple design with plush pillow-top arms. The McGann requires 12 inches of clearance behind it to fully recline. The MakingMoves arrives fully assembled, requiring no setup. The McGann also notes easy assembly and fits through 30-inch doorways.
Build Quality
Both chairs feature reinforced frames for lasting stability. The McGann Brown uses a durable reinforced frame with an engineered metal seat box supporting up to 250 pounds. The MakingMoves chair is built with a corner-blocked wood and engineered wood frame. It also includes a metal-reinforced seat for reliable everyday support. Both designs prioritize structural integrity for daily use. The McGann weighs 103 pounds, while the MakingMoves weighs 128 pounds. The additional weight of the MakingMoves may indicate a more substantial frame construction for larger users.
Choose your ideal Ashley rocker
Taller individuals needing extra space
The MakingMoves chair offers a 22-inch seat width and 23-inch depth, accommodating broader frames comfortably. Its 42-inch overall height suits taller users better than the McGann model. You get a 67-inch reclined length for full leg extension. The no-assembly design lets you start using it immediately without setup hassle.
Users preferring compact dimensions
The McGann model measures 40 inches wide and 41 inches long, fitting smaller rooms more easily. It requires only 12 inches of clearance behind it to recline fully. The 17-inch interior seat width provides a snug fit for average-sized bodies. At 103 pounds, it is lighter and easier to move if needed.
Those wanting built-in storage
Only the MakingMoves model includes convenient pop-out arm cupholders. This feature keeps beverages within easy reach while you relax. The McGann chair lacks this specific amenity. If holding a drink without a side table is important to your routine, the MakingMoves design integrates this utility directly into the armrests.
The products compared
Signature Design by Ashley McGann Rocker Recliner
Best for: Simple pull-recline and easy-clean faux leather
- Recline Mechanism
- 3-position manual
- Wall Clearance
- 12 inches
- Seat Width
- 17 inches
- Upholstery Material
- Faux leather
- Motion Type
- Rocker
- Intended Use
- Living Room
View on Amazon: Signature Design by Ashley McGann Rocker Recliner Affiliate link
The Signature Design by Ashley McGann Brown Rocker Recliner combines a faux leather upholstery with a rocker motion. It measures 40 inches wide, 41 inches deep, and 40 inches high, weighing 103 pounds. The one-pull reclining mechanism offers basic relaxation without complex controls. Its tailored walnut brown aesthetic fits well in various living spaces. This chair suits those who prefer a sturdy, easy-to-clean surface and a gentle rocking feel for daily use.
Pros
- Faux leather upholstery is durable and easy to clean
- One-pull reclining mechanism for simple operation
- Rocker motion provides gentle soothing movement
- Compact 40-inch width fits standard room layouts
Cons
- Only one recline setting via pull handle
- Heavier build at 103 pounds limits portability
- Minor assembly required with a screwdriver
Good fit if
- You want a durable, wipeable faux leather surface
- You prefer a simple one-pull recline mechanism
- You need a compact 40-inch wide chair
Skip if
- You require multiple recline positions or power controls
- You need a lightweight chair for frequent moving
- You prefer a fully assembled product with no tools
Verdict: Signature Design by Ashley McGann Rocker Recliner is a solid option for buyers seeking a durable faux leather chair with a simple pull recline and gentle rocking motion. It fits well in standard living rooms where easy maintenance and basic comfort are priorities.
Signature Design by Ashley MakingMoves Rocker Recliner
Best for: oversized buyers needing no assembly
- Recline Mechanism
- Manual pull tab
- Seat Width
- 22 inches
- Upholstery Material
- Faux leather (97% polyester, 3% PU)
- Motion Type
- Rocker
- Features
- Cup Holders
- Dimensions
- 40 × 40 × 42 inches
View on Amazon: Signature Design by Ashley MakingMoves Rocker Recliner Affiliate link
The Signature Design by Ashley MakingMoves Rocker Recliner is an oversized chair built for broader and taller individuals. It features a 22-inch seat width, 23-inch depth, and a 42-inch height. The manual pull tab reclines to a 67-inch length, while the rocker base provides gentle motion. You get faux leather upholstery and built-in cup holders in a package that requires no assembly.
Pros
- No assembly required for immediate use
- 22-inch wide seat for extra comfort
- Manual recline extends to 67 inches
- Built-in pop-out arm cup holders
Cons
- Heavy at 128 pounds
- Manual pull tab only
- Faux leather material
Good fit if
- You need a chair without assembly
- You prefer a wider 22-inch seat
- You want built-in cup holders
Skip if
- You want motorized reclining
- You prefer genuine leather
- You need a lightweight chair
Verdict: The Ashley MakingMoves Oversized Rocker Recliner suits taller buyers who want a wide, ready-to-use seat with manual controls. It fits those who value immediate setup and integrated cup holders over motorized features.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Signature Design by Ashley McGann Rocker Recliner | Signature Design by Ashley MakingMoves Rocker Recliner |
|---|---|---|
| Recline Mechanism | 3-position manual | Manual pull tab |
| Wall Clearance | 12 inches | not stated |
| Seat Width | 17 inches | 22 inches |
| Upholstery Material | Faux leather | Faux leather (97% polyester, 3% PU) |
| Reclining Mechanism | Manual | Manual |
| Motion Type | Rocker | Rocker |
| Upholstery | Faux Leather | Faux Leather |
| Features | not stated | Cup Holders |
| Intended Use | Living Room | not stated |
| Room | Living Room | not stated |
| Color | Brown | Smoke |
| Dimensions | 41 × 40 × 40 inches | 40 × 40 × 42 inches |
| Weight | 103 pounds | 128 pounds |
| Size | 0 | 40"W x 40"D x 42"H |
| Model | 1030125 | NC5330625 |
Frequently asked questions
Which recliner is heavier?
The MakingMoves Rocker Recliner weighs 128 pounds, while the McGann Brown model weighs 103 pounds. The MakingMoves chair is significantly heavier. This extra weight often indicates a sturdier build or denser materials. You should consider this if you plan to move the chair frequently.
Does the MakingMoves have cup holders?
Yes, the MakingMoves Rocker Recliner includes cup holders. The McGann Brown model does not list this feature. If you enjoy keeping drinks within reach while relaxing, the MakingMoves design offers this convenience. It is a practical addition for casual living room use.
What color options are available?
The McGann Brown recliner comes in Brown. The MakingMoves model is available in Smoke. These are the specific colors listed for each product. You should choose based on your existing room decor. The Smoke option provides a neutral tone that may differ from standard brown furniture.
Are both chairs manual recliners?
Yes, both chairs use manual reclining mechanisms. The McGann Brown uses a simple pull action. The MakingMoves also features a manual pull tab. Neither model includes motorized or power recline functions. You will need to use your own strength to adjust the footrest position.
Which model is taller?
The MakingMoves Rocker Recliner is taller at 42 inches. The McGann Brown model stands at 40 inches high. The two-inch difference may matter for taller users. The MakingMoves is also slightly deeper at 40 inches compared to the McGann's 41-inch length, though widths are identical.
Do both chairs rock?
Yes, both chairs feature a rocker motion. The McGann Brown provides a gentle rocking movement. The MakingMoves also offers a rocker base. This motion allows you to sway slightly while seated. It adds comfort without requiring any additional mechanisms or adjustments from the user.